TThe Foundr Podcast
← All episodes
Colin Darretta09 February 2021

344: How Colin Darretta Built A 1m Person Mailing List In 1 Year

5Frameworks
7Insights

Frameworks in this episode

Insights & moments

The myth-busts, hot takes, explainers, and tools worth keeping.

Hot Take· 1

Hot Take32:30

A Market Can Be Too Small for VC and Still Support a Strong Business

Darretta argues that consumer niches dismissed by venture investors can still support profitable brands with devoted customers. His holding-company thesis was to build several businesses that might each top out below venture scale but could together create a substantial economic outcome.

  • Venture investors may reject markets with limited maximum outcomes
  • That rejection can leave useful niches underserved
  • A smaller brand can still be profitable and attractive to a strategic buyer
  • Several such brands can create a larger portfolio outcome

there was a lot of niches that people haven't really touched because they go ignored by the venture community

Colin Darretta · 32:30
#venture capital#niche markets#holding company

Explainer· 1

Explainer27:30

Why Multi-Brand Campaigns Gave DojoMojo an Organic Growth Loop

Darretta says DojoMojo reached more than 10,000 brands without paid advertising. Because campaigns often involved four to six brands, a participant that wanted to repeat a successful partnership would invite another brand onto the platform, extending the network through the work itself.

  • DojoMojo's partnerships commonly involved several brands
  • Successful participants had a reason to run another campaign
  • Inviting a desired collaborator brought another brand onto the platform
  • Darretta attributes the platform's initial network growth to organic signups and word of mouth

we never did any paid advertising for it

Colin Darretta · 27:30

I'm going to invite them onto the platform

Colin Darretta · 28:00
#network effects#saas growth#collaboration

Story· 2

Story01:30

A Finance Career Became the Counterweight That Led to Wellpath

Colin Darretta describes moving from investment banking at Goldman Sachs to a large New York hedge fund. He says an intense and unhealthy work routine pushed him toward health and wellness as a personal interest, which later became the basis for Wellpath.

  • Darretta began in investment banking and hedge funds
  • Health and wellness started as a counterbalance to his work lifestyle
  • A side interest eventually became the platform for his first business

something that I became interested in as a side hustle ultimately became 02 30 uh you know the platform for my main thing

Colin Darretta · 02:00
#founder story#career change#wellness
Story03:30

Wellpath Spent Two Years Learning That a Better Product Was Not Enough

Darretta says Wellpath did far more wrong than right in its first years. He had assumed a novel, better product would naturally attract customers, then learned that he had substantially underestimated marketing and access to an audience.

  • Wellpath launched in 2015
  • The founders initially assumed product quality would attract customers
  • Darretta identifies underinvestment in marketing as an early mistake
  • The audience problem eventually led them toward partnership-led acquisition

I under-indexed how important marketing was going to be

Colin Darretta · 04:00
#early-stage#product myth#marketing

Q&A· 1

Q&A39:30

When Should Shared Holding-Company Roles Move Into Each Brand?

Darretta says the team had not fully solved the organizational complexity of operating several brands. Engineering made sense as a shared platform resource, while roles such as design could need dedicated ownership earlier; their working goal was for a brand near $20 million in revenue to have a largely dedicated team.

  • Shared engineering can handle intermittent large builds across brands
  • Brand voice may create an earlier need for a dedicated designer
  • Moving a role too early can distort the brand's profit and loss statement
  • Moving it too late can deny the brand the focus it needs
  • Darretta presents the $20 million point as a working goal, not a settled universal threshold

I'd be being dishonest with you if I said we'd completely figured that one out yet

Colin Darretta · 39:30

by the time a brand gets to about 20 million, it should have largely a dedicated team of its own

Colin Darretta · 41:00
#org design#shared services#brand teams

Takeaway· 2

Takeaway23:00

Running Low on Capital Forced Wellpath to Find a Cheaper Growth Path

Darretta candidly says the company spent unwisely early and lacked enough cash to absorb the learning period required for major paid platforms. The constraint forced the team toward scrappier acquisition, including email, partnerships, and direct response, which he credits with imposing useful discipline.

  • Early spending left too little cash for a sustained paid-media learning period
  • Darretta reports that agencies expected significant monthly spend and weak initial efficiency
  • Limited capital narrowed the team's options
  • The resulting constraint encouraged lower-cash acquisition methods

we just didn't have enough cash left in the bank

Colin Darretta · 23:30

lack of capital gave us a lack of options so it forced a certain amount of discipline on us

Colin Darretta · 11:00
#bootstrapping#capital efficiency#paid media
Takeaway43:30

Darretta Uses “This Too Shall Pass” Most When Things Are Going Well

Darretta says his father's advice helps him keep both failure and success in perspective. He especially repeats it during strong periods because good conditions will end too, while persistence and staying in the game improve the chance of surviving the next swing.

  • Darretta describes entrepreneurship as a non-linear path
  • The first two years often felt like failure to him
  • He uses the same perspective during good periods as during bad ones
  • He associates long-term success with persistence and continued effort

the good times will end just as surely as the bad times

Colin Darretta · 44:00

the people who end up succeeding over the long term are just simply the people who are able to stay in the game the longest

Colin Darretta · 44:30
#persistence#founder mindset#resilience